User blog
P10
to be in a physical condition that makes buying and using an eyegaze computer both necessary and reasonable is to live a life in hell. i think we can all admit that. i, for one, have ALS. there are those of you out there with spinal-cord injuries and other catastrophic circumstances. i think of all of you and pray for all of you all of the time.
for hardware and software engineers to create such incredible and enabling machines is testament to how deep human empathy for one another can flow. i would like to personally thank every single person who ever contributed to the design and production of this computer.
however, as wonderful as the software and the built-in cameras are, i feel that i must comment on the choice of the standard computing platform that the P10 is built upon. Intel celeron processors have always been "entry-level" products. even Intel themselves admit that every generation of celerons have been designed and marketed with that idea in mind. at a cost of over $17,000.00 USD, there should be absolutely NOTHING "entry-level" about the P10! software upgrades in the future may well be impossible. what then? that brings me to the real problem i am faced with. i don't know about any of you, but my P10 has an integrated mono sound-producing chipset instead of an actual sound card. it is barely capable of delivering the synthesized "voice" that we've all come to rely upon, let alone delivering the music that i know helps every single one of us deal with our lives from one day to the next. sure, this is a "speech generating device", and we all know what that means, but c'mon guys (at tobii & the us govt), do we not deserve a simple, fully-functioning stereo sound card??; one that we can plug our external speakers into?? is that too much to expect?? the difference in cost would be about $40.00 USD. it is an obvious and foregone conclusion that the P10 is designed to replace completely any computer that a patient currently uses and even the most basic of those systems (you know - the ones with the celeron processors) came with real sound cards. i wanted the D10 model but was told that it had been discontinued. so much for thinking i had all the necessary information.
Well pointed comment. The technology of the device is awesome, however our concerns too are upgrades as well as portablity of the device. The weight of the device and battery pack are not ideal. Is TOBII looking as this? As I said, we are just getting the P10 for our daughter and I looks like Microsoft media will work to for music- are we mistaken?
Dear Robert and Jamie
You have both raised two important questions. Let me try to answer them.
Processor and computer capacity in the P10. Well, depending on how you compare it, it can be either really great or really poor..
Compared to any other speech generating device it is still, after two years, a product with one of the best specifications and indeed powerful enough to run any communication application.
Compared to a new computer it is poor. But a computer is meant to do so much more than communicating.
Now. P10 is a speech generating device and got the specification for that purpose.
But there is also an option of controlling another computer with the P10. There is a function in Windows called “Remote desktop”, which makes it possible to get access to another computer with any specification or software. Just like with the D10, that was a computer screen with built in eye tracker. If you are interested you can contact Tobii Support to get the details on how it is done. We will also post it as “Tip of the week” thanks to your comment.
More powerful sound
Yes, the P10 has got a small 2W speaker aiming away from the user, towards the person he or she is talking to. But if you want a more powerful sound you can always connect external speakers or a headphone via a USB soundcard. That’s powerful! And does not cost that much either!
Hope this was useful for you
Roger Henriksson
Product Manager, MyTobii
Hello, the option of controlling another computer with P10 sounds wonderful! Personally I am very interested in this option for my son. Can you get with that function 'Remote desktop' access also to another for instance school network computer/software? I am looking forward to seeing the "Tip of the week"! Thank you so much! Mihaela